Police make changes to comply with US Supreme Court's ruling on mobile phone searches

Tami Abdollah / The Associated Press
June 26, 2014 05:39 AM

FILE - In this Tuesday, April 29, 2014 file photo, a Supreme Court visitor takes pictures with her cell phone outside the Supreme Court in Washington, during a hearing to consider whether police may search cell phones found on people they arrest without first getting a warrant. The Supreme Court ruling barring police from searching cell phones without a warrant had an immediate impact as police nationwide were briefed during roll calls, new procedures were issued and prosecutors discussed the potential impact to possibly thousands of pending court cases. From Los Angeles to New York, and in San Diego, Chicago and Houston, departments met to discuss the unanimous ruling issued Wednesday, June 25, 2014, that prohibits law enforcement from searching an arrestees’ cell phone without a warrant unless a person’s safety or life may be in danger and could make it harder for officers to quickly find incriminating evidence. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, file)

LOS ANGELES, Calif. - Police officers are being briefed during roll calls, new procedures are in place, and prosecutors are considering the effect on potentially thousands of pending court cases after the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling that restricts police searches of mobile phones.

From Los Angeles to New York, and in San Diego, Chicago and Houston, officials met to discuss Wednesday's unanimous ruling that could make it harder for officers to quickly find incriminating evidence. The ruling prohibits law enforcement from searching an arrestee's phone without a warrant unless a person's safety or life may be in danger.

Because mobile phone technology has so rapidly advanced over the last decade, more information than ever before — including personal documents, photos and emails — is now stored on these devices. For investigators, they can be a treasure trove of suspects' pictures with fellow gang members, not to mention text messages and call records that help police find accomplices or victims.

Few, if any, in law enforcement circles were surprised by the high court's ruling, and they said many cautious investigators were already getting warrants to ensure evidence doesn't get tossed out of trials. But they also universally acknowledged that it would make their jobs more difficult, especially for the rank-and-file patrol officer.

"It's going to be more cumbersome, it's going to take more work, it's going to take more time," said Los Angeles County sheriff's Lt. Kent Wegener, of the Major Crimes Bureau. Wegener said his investigators routinely seek search warrants for their cases.

In Houston, prosecutors were already treating mobile phones as personal property with privacy rights and advising police officers that if they weren't given permission, they'd need a search warrant to access the devices, said Bill Exley, a prosecutor in the Harris County district attorney's office.

The Constitution's Fourth Amendment requires police generally to have a judge sign a warrant that's based on "probable cause," or evidence that a crime has been committed. But cellphones have been treated like any other item in an arrestee's possession, meaning they could be examined to ensure the officer's safety and prevent the destruction of evidence.

The Supreme Court's decision examined two cases that arose after arrests in San Diego and Boston. In San Diego, police found indications of gang membership when they looked through a defendant's smartphone, and prosecutors used video and photographs from the phone to persuade a jury to convict him of attempted murder and other charges. In Boston, police used the call log on an arrested man's flip phone to lead them to his home, where they found drugs, a gun and ammunition.

Thousands of pending court cases could be altered or dropped because of what would now be considered illegally obtained evidence as a result of the decision, said Oregon defence attorney Bronson James, who authored an amicus brief for the plaintiffs. Whether that'll happen is unclear, and prosecutors are working to limit the case's retroactive impact.

The ruling may also ultimately challenge law enforcement's use of other technology, James said, such as the U.S. government's bulk data collection or the "Stingray," a device that sweeps up cellphone data in a given area.

It can take anywhere from a few hours for a judge to sign off on a state search warrant to a few days for a federal one.

Though the ruling provides leeway for situations where a person's safety or life is in danger, authorities have concerns about whether information or opportunities might be missed. The San Diego County district attorney's office has had conversations with law enforcement on how to expedite search warrant requests when only a couple judges might be on call at night or over the weekend.

San Diego County's chief deputy district attorney, Summer Stephan, said human traffickers often run their businesses from their cellphones, arranging prices and schedules for girls and customers by text message.

Though the ruling allows for emergency situations, "sometimes you don't know if you have that until you look," Stephan said. "You don't know if the girl you were already able to rescue is the only girl until you look at the phone and see if there's communication with another girl."

The decision addresses worries that information may be erased remotely, allowing police to seize the phone and turn it off or remove its battery. Police can also place it in a special bag to isolate it from radio waves.

___

Tami Abdollah can be reached at http://www.twitter.com/latams . Associated Press writers Juan A. Lozano in Houston, Jason Keyser in Chicago, Nigel Duara in Portland, Oregon, and Jacob Pearson in New York contributed to this report.


© Coast Reporter
Coast Reporter

Email to a Friend

Close

QUESTION OF THE WEEK POLL

Do we do enough to encourage young people to vote?

or  view results

Popular Coast Reporter

Community Event Calendar


Find out what's happening in your community and submit your own local events.